Skip to main content

COMMENT ON THE DRAFT SHORT-TERM LETTING BY-LAW

From "Comment on the City's Draft Short-Term Letting By-Law"

Go to the project

I am submitting these comments as a Cape Town property owner who currently operates two properties as short-term rentals.

My concern is that the proposed framework does not appear to make sufficient distinction between small-scale property owners and large commercial accommodation businesses.

Small-scale operators should not be treated in the same manner as hotels and large commercial operators

We own two dedicated short-term rental properties, which we manage as a small family-run operation. During the quieter winter months, we also make use of mid-term rentals. Our annual occupancy is approximately 50–60%.

Our operation is therefore very different in scale and structure from a hotel, guest house or commercial operator managing dozens or even hundreds of accommodation units.

I appreciate the City’s objective of creating fairness within the accommodation industry. However, fairness does not necessarily require identical treatment of fundamentally different types and scales of businesses.

Hotels and large accommodation establishments benefit from economies of scale and generally have dedicated administrative staff and systems. Small property owners often personally perform the reservations, guest communication, administration, maintenance coordination, cleaning management, bookkeeping and compliance.

The financial impact on small operators

The proposed change in rates categorisation could have a significant financial impact on owners such as ourselves.

Our two properties are each valued at approximately R1.6 million to R1.8 million.

Using the City’s current 2026/27 residential and Business and Commercial rates merely as an illustration, reclassification of properties in this value range could result in an additional municipal rates burden of approximately R20,000 to R22,000 per property per year.

For our two-property operation, this represents approximately R40,000 to R44,000 in additional annual property rates.

This is a substantial additional cost for a small operator and illustrates why I believe scale should form part of the City’s approach.

A two-property owner does not have the same ability to absorb regulatory and rating costs as a hotel, large guesthouse or commercial operator with dozens or hundreds of rooms.

I therefore respectfully request that the City consider either a separate rates category, a reduced commercial rate, a rebate, or a graduated system for small-scale short-term letting operators rather than moving all qualifying properties directly into the same Business and Commercial category.

Necessity and proportionality of additional regulation

I would also ask the City to consider whether the additional level of regulation and information collection proposed by this By-law is necessary and proportionate, particularly in relation to small operators.

As property owners, we already pay municipal property rates and charges. Income earned from our rental properties is already subject to the applicable national tax obligations, and responsible operators already carry the administrative burden associated with declaring and accounting for that income.

The proposed framework would now introduce another layer of registration, reporting, information sharing and compliance at municipal level, while potentially also substantially increasing the municipal rates payable on the same properties.

I understand that the City requires an effective means of identifying properties that it believes should fall within a different municipal rating category. However, I believe it is reasonable to ask whether achieving this objective requires the creation of an extensive new compliance burden for every short-term rental owner.

The fact that information may assist enforcement does not, by itself, mean that every possible piece of information should be required from individual property owners.

I therefore ask the City to apply the principles of necessity, proportionality and data minimisation when determining what information owners are required to provide.

Where the City can obtain sufficient information directly from booking platforms to establish whether a property meets the relevant criteria, owners should not be required to separately collect, calculate and submit the same information.

I would also ask that the City clearly explain what information will be collected from property owners and booking platforms, why each category of information is necessary, how frequently it must be supplied, how long it will be retained, who will have access to it, and what safeguards will apply to that information.

For small operators, the cumulative effect of additional taxation, registration and compliance should also be considered. Regulation should address a clearly identified problem without creating unnecessary bureaucracy for responsible property owners who are already meeting their existing tax and municipal obligations.

Administrative burden on small operators

One of my other primary concerns is the additional administrative burden created by the proposed registration and reporting requirements.

For a large hotel or commercial accommodation operator, additional compliance may be absorbed by existing administrative staff. For a small operator, every additional reporting requirement translates directly into additional working hours.

In our case, this would mean either taking time away from our other work and family responsibilities or employing someone to deal with additional administration. The cost of compliance is therefore disproportionately greater for small operators.

I ask the City to adopt a principle of minimum necessary administration.

Where information such as listing availability and occupancy can be supplied directly and securely by booking platforms, individual owners should not be required to duplicate that reporting manually.

Registration should ideally be a simple process completed once, with owners required only to update information when material circumstances change.

Availability should not be treated as equivalent to commercial use

I am particularly concerned about using the number of nights a property is available for short-term letting as the determining measure of commercial use.

Availability and actual commercial activity are not the same thing.

Our properties may be made available for much of the year, but our actual annual occupancy is only approximately 50–60%. We do not receive commercial accommodation income for every night that a property is theoretically available.

Conversely, a highly profitable property could potentially be offered exclusively during Cape Town’s peak tourism periods for fewer than 50% of the nights in a year, achieve extremely high occupancy and nightly rates, and nevertheless remain below an availability-based threshold.

This raises the possibility of two properties with very different levels of actual commercial activity being categorised differently simply because of the number of nights their calendars were left open.

I respectfully request that the City reconsider whether availability alone is the fairest measurement and investigate a methodology that takes account of actual occupied short-term room nights, or a combination of availability, actual short-term occupancy and the scale of the operator.

Recognition of mixed short- and mid-term rental models

The proposed framework should also clearly accommodate properties that move between short-term and mid-term residential rentals during different seasons.

Cape Town has a highly seasonal tourism economy. During quieter periods, we place our properties into mid-term rentals rather than leaving them vacant.

This provides accommodation to people needing housing for several weeks or months while simultaneously allowing property owners to maintain sustainable occupancy outside the peak tourism season.

I ask the City to ensure that periods during which a property is genuinely occupied under a mid- or longer-term residential rental arrangement are clearly excluded when calculating its short-term letting activity.

A proportional alternative

Rather than applying substantially the same regulatory and rating approach to all operators, I ask the City to consider:

1. Creating a small-operator category, for example for individual owners operating one or two short-term rental properties.

2. Providing a simplified registration and reporting process for these operators.

3. Ensuring that information already supplied directly by booking platforms is not also required to be manually submitted by property owners.

4. Reconsidering the use of availability alone as the determining measure of commercial short-term letting and giving greater consideration to actual short-term occupancy.

5. Clearly excluding periods of genuine mid- and long-term residential letting from short-term letting calculations.

6. Introducing a graduated rates mechanism, reduced commercial rate or rebate for small-scale operators rather than automatically subjecting them to the full Business and Commercial property rate.

7. Applying regulatory and administrative requirements proportionately according to the scale and nature of the operation.

8. Limiting information collected from individual owners to information that is demonstrably necessary and cannot reasonably be obtained directly from booking platforms.

Conclusion

Short-term rentals form part of Cape Town’s tourism accommodation ecosystem and range from individual homeowners and small family-run operations to professional businesses managing very large portfolios of properties.

A regulatory framework should recognise these differences.

I support reasonable accountability and responsible operation of short-term rentals. However, I believe the City should demonstrate that any additional regulation, information collection and financial burden imposed on property owners is necessary and proportionate to the problem it seeks to address.

For a small operator such as ourselves, the combined impact of potentially R40,000 or more in additional annual municipal rates together with increased administrative obligations is material.

Small operators should not have to absorb an ever-increasing administrative burden simply because technology makes additional monitoring possible. Where the City can achieve its legitimate objectives through existing information, platform-level reporting or less burdensome measures, those options should be preferred.

I therefore respectfully request that the City reconsider the proposed framework to ensure that legitimate small-scale operators are not subjected to disproportionate administrative and financial burdens intended to regulate commercial accommodation activity on a fundamentally different scale.

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed Short-Term Letting By-Law.

Comments

Commenting is not possible because this project is currently not active.

Share

Posted by

Current status

proposed