Objection to the Proposed Short-Term Letting Classification and Rating Methodology
From "Comment on the City's Draft Short-Term Letting By-Law"
Go to the project
Dear City of Cape Town,
I am a Cape Town property owner whose residential property is also made available for short-term letting, and I wish to submit the following comments on the Draft Short-Term Letting By-Law, 2026.
I support a fair and transparent system that enables the City to distinguish genuinely commercial accommodation businesses from residential properties that are made available for short-term letting. I do, however, have concerns regarding the way in which the proposed 50% threshold will be calculated and applied.
My property is a large residential home with multiple bedrooms and is rented as a single property rather than as individual rooms. The definition of “total annual room nights” as the “maximum annual capacity of a property for short-term letting” requires much greater clarity.
In particular, I request that the City clarify:
- How room nights will be calculated where an entire multi-bedroom residential property is rented as one unit rather than individual rooms.
- Whether the 50% threshold will be determined according to actual guest occupancy or merely the number of nights on which a property is advertised or shown as available.
I believe commercial categorisation should be based principally on actual short-term letting activity and occupation, rather than theoretical availability. A property may remain listed online throughout the year while being occupied by its owner, undergoing maintenance, blocked for personal use, or simply receiving no bookings.
There is also a risk that the proposed methodology could disproportionately affect owners of larger residential homes. For example, treating every bedroom in a 10-bedroom home as a separate available “room night”, despite the property being marketed and rented as one dwelling, may not accurately reflect the property's actual commercial use.
I would therefore request that the final By-Law contain a precise and transparent calculation methodology, including practical examples for whole-home rentals, multi-bedroom properties, part-year rentals and owner-occupied properties.
I am also concerned about the breadth of section 7, particularly the provision allowing the collection of “any other data relevant to the implementation of this By-Law”. I request that the categories of information that may be collected be clearly defined and limited to information reasonably necessary for determining the property's rates categorisation, with appropriate safeguards regarding frequency, retention and use of that information.
Section 11 also provides for potentially significant criminal penalties, including imprisonment of up to six months, for failure to comply with any obligation imposed under the By-Law. I respectfully submit that administrative or inadvertent non-compliance should first be dealt with through reasonable notice and an opportunity to remedy the breach, with criminal sanctions reserved for deliberate or repeated serious non-compliance.
Finally, the transitional provisions do not establish a specific grace period, but instead leave this to a future public notice. Property owners and booking platforms will need adequate time to register, amend listings and understand the City's reporting requirements. I therefore request that a reasonable minimum implementation period be incorporated into the final By-Law.
I support sensible regulation of the short-term letting sector, but believe the final framework should be clear, proportionate and should distinguish genuine commercial accommodation businesses from residential property owners who make their homes available for short-term rental.
Thank you for considering my submission.
Kind regards,
Dominique
